Camille, I understand your confusion and share it. The available information is all very conflicting. Toys that are made from soft PVC are everywhere.
THE SAFETY AND BENEFITS OF PVC TOYS
PVC - Used by toymakers for more than 40 years
Toy makers around the world have been using PVC for more than 40 years to make some of the best known and most popular toys and children's products. Why? Because PVC makes good, safe toys that are durable, easy to clean and are fun for children of all ages!
In addition to its safety record, toymakers also use PVC because of its versatility; it can be easily formulated to be flexible or rigid, or to be virtually any colour of the rainbow. PVC's durability helps toys to withstand even the most rugged play, and parents can appreciate the fact that it can be easily cleaned, helping to keep children safe from germs.
Plasticisers and their use in PVC toys
To make PVC soft and flexible it is necessary to use substances known as plasticisers to make the material pliable.
The most commonly used plasticisers to make PVC soft and flexible are phthalates (pronounced thal-ates). They are a family of chemical substances that have been in use for more than half a century.
Phthalates are used in literally thousands of everyday items, many of which we have come to take for granted as we strive to improve our lifestyles and make everything around us better, safer and more efficient. Indeed, it is thanks to phthalates that we are able to enjoy the benefits of many different types of electrical cables, household items like shower curtains and garden hoses, protective clothing, flooring and even life-saving medical devices.
In all the time that we have benefited from their use there has not been a single known case of anyone ever having been harmed as a result of the use of phthalates. And yet they continue to be a centre of concern about possible effects on our health and the environment, particularly when used in toys.
The use of phthalates in toys and childcare items has been restricted in the European Union since December 1999. From January 17 2007 further restrictions on their use in toys will come into force on a permanent basis.
The PVC Toys Information Centre aims to help you understand more about plasticisers, to provide information on European legislation and to explain why you should treat concerns about health and environmental effects with caution. With these facts we hope you will be able to arrive at your own informed opinion.
PVC Toys Information Centre
Link to toys made from soft PVC.
PVC (Vinyl) Plastic:* an evaluation of safety issues** (Introduction and Home Page) Some Toys Containing Soft PVC Fisher-Price, Inc.
Animal Families
Baby Baseball (Polypropylene & PVC)
Dolls with vinyl heads/arms,
legs - Mary Doll, Jenny Doll, Natalie Doll,
Audrey Doll, Baby Ann Doll, Mikey Doll,
Elisabeth Doll, Joey Doll, Honey Doll, My
Friend Mandy Doll, My Friend Jenny Doll,
Becky Doll, Muffy Doll, Billie Doll, Bobbie
Doll.
Push/pull toys: Sunny Fish, Barky, Peter Pig,
Playful Puppy, Allie Gater, Ducky Flip Flap,
Struttin' Donald Duck
The Woodsey's Store (vinyl tree); Dancing
Animals Mobile; Squeaky Bear; Sandy Starfish;
Sam the Clam; Terry Tape; Amusement Park
Little People (vinyl play mat); Baby Activity
Table; Clatterpillar; Surprise Sounds Animals
Gerber Products Co.
Looney Tunes Lovables:
Cooling Ring Teether, Rattle Teether,
Water-filled Soother
Teethers: Gem Collection
Safari Pals
Charms-on-a-Ring
Clear and Soft Pacifiers
Squeeze Toys: Darling Duckie
Peek-A-Pals
Kiddie Kruiser
Dippy Duck Bath Toy
Safety 1st, Inc.
Teethersaurus
Sof' Key Teethers
Earth Care Teether
Sports Fan Teether
Sof' Sport Teether
Interactive Discovery Toy
Hasbro, Inc.
Baby Duckie
Gloworm 5720 (PVC head; nylon body)
Very Soft Baby(PVC head)
Teethe 'n' Toy
Soft Animal Teether Assortment
Disney Babies Squeakin' Pal Assortment
Disney Babies Teethe 'n' Travel 33199, Disney
Babies Hold 'n' Soothe Teether
Darling Animals Teether
Happy L'il Fruits Teether
Soft Walking Wheels
Playskool Baby, Inc. Subsidiary of Hasbro
Animo Dentition
Funny Face Teether Rattle
Disney Babies Mickey Collection
Teether Album
First Rattle
Kids II
Farm Friends Teething Toys
Musical Teether
Quackin' Tub Toy
Scrub Buddies
Teether Friends 3891(ears are PVC)
Tub Toy
Mattel, Inc
Toy Story Mr Mike
Blue Classic Pooh Dishes 6 piece dinner set,
Classic Pooh Baby Book Collection 1 & 2
Silbiditos Tiger ("Tigger")
Infant Gift Set (star)
Infant Gift Set (head)
Infant Gift Set (squeeze bulb)
Baby Donald Squeak 'n Fun
Squirt 'n Splash Elephant
Lion King
Jungle Friend Babies
Winged Wisdom Pet Bird Magazine - Dangers of soft PVC toys and vinyl for pet parrots & exotic birds - Birds, Birds, Birds
A lot of these companies have now eliminated the use of soft PVC in their toys.
Safety 1st, Inc. stopped using PVC for infant teethers over a year ago, according to consumer relations staffer Patricia Andrews (phone call, 1/2/01).
I believe
Gerber has also stopped using it, but I don't have documentation to back up my statement.
Usually toys are NOT labelled as PVC or ‘vinyl’, or marked with the PVC symbol ("3" in the "re-cycle triangle"). Concerned consumers should ask the retailer or the manufacturer to confirm whether a toy is made of PVC or not.